How to Find the Right Digital Agency for Your Business: A Comprehensive Guide

More and more companies are reaching a point where they need to outsource these services. Whether you’ve outgrown your internal capacities or are pursuing an aggressive growth strategy, it’s crucial to find a web agency with a high-quality offering tailored to your needs. So, where do you start?

It’s important to select an internet agency that focuses on a long-term strategy, not just service delivery. Good web agencies take the time to work with their clients not only as solution providers but also as business growth advisors.

With no shortage of internet agencies offering blanket guarantees, you should find one that focuses on your business first. Digital agencies that overpromise and say "yes" to everything are often the ones that underdeliver. A good web agency will challenge your expectations and understanding from the start.

As with any significant investment, you need to conduct thorough due diligence. Once you’ve made the decision, you’ll be spending hard-earned money to market your business. You can’t afford to make a mistake.

Equip yourself for success with our top recommendations for choosing the right digital agency for your business.

Define Your Project Goals

Your hiring decision will largely be driven by your business goals and budget. Whether it’s revenue targets, leads per month, or ranking positions, having clear goals allows an internet agency to understand and assess whether your goals are achievable within your budget. Without clear objectives, complex projects can drift in uncertain directions, misaligned with overarching business goals. It’s crucial that companies develop a digital strategy that supports their business objectives before defining project requirements and hiring a service provider. Many projects fail due to a lack of objectives.

You should identify not only the desired outcome but also the KPIs (Key Performance Indicators) by which success will be measured. Otherwise, you could invest heavily in a project without being able to gauge its success.

Know Your Budget

When developing your project budget, consider three things:

1. What you can afford,
2. What kind of ROI is acceptable, and
3. What goals you want to achieve.

Start by reviewing your overall budget and deciding what you can spend. Stay open-minded at this stage. You may not have a precise idea of costs. It’s more about the ROI than the hard costs. Your campaigns/projects don’t necessarily need to be expensive to achieve the desired ROI. Remember to put your agreements regarding the budget in a contract.

Planning a more complex web or e-commerce project? Discuss with your internet agency whether the allocated budget is sufficient for your project goals.

Determine Your Service Mix

Before contacting an internet agency, have a clear idea of the services you’re interested in. The better you understand your individual requirements for the various services, the more insightful your discussions with a potential digital agency will be.

Do you want to hand over the work to a provider and let them handle everything so you can focus on your core business? Do you want a digital agency to act as an extension of your internal team? How much time can you and your team afford to work with an agency? Do you prefer working with a large web agency that offers a wide range of services or with a niche agency specializing in a specific type of marketing with deep expertise?

There are pros and cons to each approach. Ultimately, it’s about how you want to manage the relationship.

The service mix also depends on your target audience and goals. A successful digital agency will conduct thorough market analysis and provide recommendations on the best channels and services for your audience and its segments. Beware of internet agencies that seem to push their most profitable products and services rather than those that best address your campaign’s core objectives. A good web agency will recommend the right services and define them clearly.

For services requiring your input, such as content provision or result review and approval, ensure you can realistically deliver this input within a reasonable timeframe. Lastly, consider your internal capabilities and only outsource what you need expertise for, to minimize reliance on third parties and build internal know-how. For example, someone on your team might be better suited to write your blog and social posts due to their skills and business knowledge.

Look for Customized Solutions

It’s important to consider the culture and approach of a company. You want to work with a team that takes the time to truly understand your mission. Too many digital agencies pull a generic marketing strategy from the drawer and apply it to multiple businesses. Every business situation is unique and deserves a unique solution.

Some digital agencies focus primarily on bringing in as many leads as possible, offering pre-packaged services to businesses in various niches with different needs. An off-the-shelf digital marketing strategy will never be as effective as a customized one and can lead to serious issues by neglecting critical business considerations.

If an internet agency has taken the time to analyze your competition, inquire about your goals and ambitions, and draft a realistic high-level strategy for your campaign or project, they are likely to bring the same diligence to their work for you. Ask your potential internet agencies how they will address your unique business challenges and assess how personal and detailed their responses are.

Check the Digital Agency’s Market and Online Presence

Before meeting with a web agency, check their website for previous clients, campaigns, and results. You can get a sense of how a digital agency thinks and operates by looking at their online presence and marketing materials. If you notice typos or poor designs in their own materials, you can rightfully question how they will handle your work. You can also get a sense of what they value by seeing what they emphasize.

A lack of transparency is a red flag here. Experience is important. Don’t just ask how long the internet agency has been around but also how experienced the strategists/project staff are who will be working on your campaign/project. A team with diverse experience in various industries (including yours) is very valuable.

When meeting with a digital agency, prepare a list of various technical questions to test the staff’s capabilities. Testing them will reveal not only their skills but also their transparency. A good web agency will honestly tell you what is possible and what is not.

You can also examine how well the internet agency markets itself. If you’re looking for SEO agencies, check their domain authority. If you’re concerned with social contacts, look at their Facebook page. Find a digital agency that practices what they preach. Check Their References

Look for Customer Reviews

Before working with a web agency, check their references. Ask to see detailed case studies. Smaller internet agencies (1-10 employees) usually have many Google reviews. Read these B2B reviews and do thorough research. For most providers listed on Feedbax, we have already integrated the relevant Google reviews.

For more demanding and larger providers, we have developed a special feedback solution that can provide the necessary transparency for your hiring decision. Example reviews can be found here.

If there are not enough customer reviews available: Ask for references from current and past clients. Then contact these clients to see if they delivered what they promised. If they exaggerate their results, they may overpromise what they can do for you.

If they list current or past clients on their website, it’s a good idea to randomly select a few and call them to check their experiences.

Share Your Own Experiences with Other Clients

You’ll find how valuable authentic customer voices can be for your hiring decision. Clients willing to share their experiences with other clients can protect you from significant investment mistakes.

The market is flooded with capable and less competent providers, and your market research becomes more confusing and difficult by the day. Be one of the clients who take action by sharing your agency experiences transparently and authentically with others.

Customer reviews on Feedbax are verified, detailed, and unbiased. We aim to better organize your market research and make your provider search more transparent.

We understand that your time is limited, and you have a lot on your plate. That’s why we offer our free interview service to minimize your review effort. The feedback interview takes a maximum of 15 minutes. In just 15 minutes, you can help prevent major investment mistakes.

Ask About the Internet Agency’s Project Team

Often, the people pitching to your company aren’t the ones doing the work afterward. You should ask who on the agency side will actually work on your project and what experience these people have. Request current CVs from the potential project team.

In large digital agencies, your work may be passed on to less experienced or junior team members. Would that be acceptable to you?

Understand the Web Agency’s Project Approach

You want to ensure you understand the internet agency’s approach. Can you provide the necessary resources for the project methodology to be practiced? For example, the agile methodology SCRUM may require increased input from your company during the project to deliver high-quality results.

Ask potential digital agencies for a one-day workshop to go through recurring project alignments with your project team using concrete examples. This will help you better judge whether you can imagine working closely with the internet agency. Did they prepare and conduct the workshop well? How efficient was the coordination with your team? Were you satisfied with the final result? Could you understand and consider the workshop structure meaningful?

Choose a Local Digital Agency

Look locally. Working with a local web agency is always helpful for the relationship and communication, both crucial for success. Ask if the internet agency outsources work. An internal team shows that the digital agency values quality and wants to maintain full control over their work.

Once you’ve selected the final key candidates, it’s time to find out if you truly understand each other. If you or your team can get along personally with the internet agency’s project team, you are on the best path to a successful and collaborative relationship. This makes it easier to overcome challenges and explore innovative new ground.

It’s About Value

When it comes down to it, you must trust the people you select. It’s a significant investment. You can’t afford to waste money or the opportunity.

You need to be confident that the digital agency you choose has your best interests at heart and can deliver what they promise – in terms of technology, content, social media strategy, cross-platform measurements, marketing services, advertising, online presence, and email marketing, to name a few.

It’s not about finding the cheapest web agency. There are many low-cost providers out there. Look for a creative internet agency that offers the best value. This might mean spending a bit more initially, but like most business decisions, it’s not about the cost, it’s about the results and ROI.

Need Help selecting the right agency?

Short on time for research and need free support in selecting a provider? We’ll do it for you – for free! Based on your requirements, we can identify and introduce the best digital agencies to you.

How It Works: